Economist Peter Schiff issued a stark warning against President Donald Trump’s proposal for a “$2,000-per-person tariff dividend,” arguing the plan is economically self-defeating and would “defeat the very purpose of the tariffs.”
Tariff Dividends ‘Defeats’ The Purpose Of Levying Duties
In a post on the X platform on Monday, Schiff, the chief economist & global strategist at Europac.com, contended that the total cost of the proposed dividends would “exceed tariff revenue.”
He further argued that instead of bolstering the U.S. economy, the payouts would lead to an increased trade deficit.
“Consumers will use the extra income to buy more expensive imports, despite the tariffs,” Schiff wrote, concluding this would “[increase] our trade deficit.”
Every American Will Receive ‘At Least’ $2,000 From Tariffs
The criticism came in response to President Trump’s Nov. 9 social media post calling tariff opponents “FOOLS!” and touting a “Record Stock Market Price.”
Trump claimed the U.S. is “taking in Trillions of Dollars” from levies, which would be used to “pay down our ENORMOUS DEBT” and fund the “dividend of at least $2000 a person (not including high-income people!).”
See Also: Trump Says Every American Will Receive ‘At Least’ $2,000 From Tariffs; Scott Bessent Has This To Say On How It Will Reach People
Stimulus Boost Or Inflation “3rd Wave”?
Schiff’s skepticism joins a divided reaction from other financial commentators. Some analysts viewed the proposal as a form of market-boosting stimulus. Anthony Pompliano noted that “Stocks and bitcoin only know to go higher in response to stimulus.”
While Shay Boloor of Futurum Equities framed the plan as “returning tariff proceeds to taxpayers” and declared, “Stimulus checks are back.”
However, others echoed Schiff’s concerns about the plan’s inflationary potential. Otavio Costa of Crescat Capital posted a chart comparing current conditions to the 1970s, warning, “You can’t cure inflation by giving people money to spend, running a 6% government deficit, and having the Fed cut interest rates.” He advised investors to “stay focused on hard assets.”
Bessent Says Dividend Might Take Many Forms
Adding to the debate, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent suggested the “$2,000 dividend” may not be a direct check as many, including the experts, had assumed.
In an appearance on ABC News, Bessent said the rebate could come in “lots of forms,” including “substantial deductions” in taxes. He implied the $2,000 figure might represent the cumulative value of other tax-cut proposals rather than a direct payment.
The SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSE:SPY) and Invesco QQQ Trust ETF (NASDAQ:QQQ), which track the S&P 500 index and Nasdaq 100 index, respectively, were higher in premarket on Monday. The SPY was up 0.97% at $677.49, while the QQQ advanced 1.54% to $619.14, according to Benzinga Pro data.
Read Next:
As Record 40-Day Shutdown Nears End, History Shows Stocks Rally 12 Months Later With S&P 500 Averaging 12.3% Gain
Disclaimer: This content was partially produced with the help of AI tools and was reviewed and published by Benzinga editors.
Image via Shutterstock
AAPLApple Inc$269.420.35%OverviewQCOMQualcomm Inc$173.551.56%QQQInvesco QQQ Trust, Series 1$619.061.53%SPYSPDR S&P 500$677.560.98%Market News and Data brought to you by Benzinga APIs
