Member-only story
Lines Crossed: How ICE Became America’s Unchecked Police Force
From Law Enforcement to Political Weapon: How Administrations Use ICE to Signal Toughness
Lines Crossed: How ICE Became America’s Unchecked Police Force
“In Washington, cruelty isn’t always a mistake — sometimes it’s the message.”
The Optics of Fear
For two decades, presidents from both parties have used ICE not just as an enforcement agency, but as a stage — a theater of toughness meant to reassure the fearful and rally the faithful.
From televised raids to choreographed press releases, ICE’s work has become as much about optics as outcomes.
The agency was created to enforce civil immigration law.
Instead, it became a symbolic instrument of power — wielded to project strength, distract from policy failures, and remind Americans who holds the keys to belonging.
When ICE arrests a hundred people in a single operation, it makes headlines. When it abuses a hundred thousand quietly in detention, it barely makes a footnote.
Because in politics, visibility is everything — and ICE has become the perfect visual shorthand for control.
