Editor’s note: Ms. Gibson writes in response to a previous letter Ostriches must be culled.
—–
To the editor:
After watching the live videos from the farm over several months, I found many of the ‘claims’ the CFIA (Canadian Food Inspection Agency) made in their press releases were not completely accurate.
For context, I wish to present the following points for your consideration:
Biosecurity Protocols: Reports and online sources indicate that CFIA and RCMP personnel were observed without full biosecurity equipment (e.g., on top of hay bales). This appears to contradict their claims of a high-risk contamination situation and suggests an inconsistency that needs addressing. International Interest: The United States, Canada’s largest agricultural trade partner, reportedly expressed interest in taking the ostriches for research. That fact contradicts the CFIA’s claim that their actions were necessary to protect Canada’s agricultural trade relationships. Expert Opinions: The surviving birds were potentially healthy. I urge you to consider the statements made by experts such as Ariana Klappert, the American Ostrich Association, and Dr. Jeff Wilson of Novometrix, who has questioned the necessity and methods of the culling. Formal Complaints: Please note that both Animal Justice, a national animal law organization, and Shawn Rickard have reportedly filed formal legal and/or criminal complaints regarding the CFIA’s conduct during the cull. Criminal code on animal cruelty: s.65, s.445.1, and potentially s.446.
Ultimately, the CFIA handled the situation poorly. After all, they are the professionals, the supposed authority; they are responsible for the suffering of the animals.
Thank you,
Kelly Gibson
Calgary
