A recent investigation has revealed discrepancies surrounding the fatalities during the Kumbh Mela, the world’s largest religious gathering in India. Official reports tally the death toll at 37; however, additional findings suggest that this number may be significantly understated.
The investigation indicates that compensation payments were issued to the families of at least 26 additional individuals not included in the official count of fatalities. Furthermore, there are 18 deaths associated with the event for which no compensation was provided at all.
On March 25, a group of plainclothes officers from Uttar Pradesh traveled to Bihar to distribute cash to families affected by the tragedy. During these visits, family members received 500,000 rupees (approximately $5,758) in compensation. For example, Dhananjay Gond, whose mother Tara Devi died in the January 29 crush, confirmed: “Officers from UP came and gave us 500,000 rupees. We have received it.”
The governmental mechanism for documenting fatalities seems flawed. For Tara Devi, her son reported that this payment was merely an initial installment of a promised total of 2.5 million rupees. The remaining 2 million rupees has not yet been received.
The Uttar Pradesh government claims that 2.5 million rupees were paid to families of 35 victims. The investigation has uncovered a family that received a check for 2.5 million rupees, while payments to the remaining victims were processed differently — through bank transfers rather than cash.
The investigation also uncovered that families had to sign documents that inaccurately attributed the deaths to health issues instead of the crush itself, as the state does not normally provide compensation for natural deaths during the Kumbh Mela.
The investigation team conducted extensive interviews across several states in India, verifying 82 deaths with strong evidence while excluding those cases lacking confirmations. Over 100 families were spoken to, and several were still awaiting acknowledgment of their loved ones’ deaths by the government.
Analysis revealed multiple locations where crowd crush incidents occurred on January 29, contradicting claims from officials that only one major incident took place. Clear patterns emerged identifying four distinct locations where fatalities were confirmed.
Despite the gravity of their findings, the investigation faced obstacles in obtaining answers from government officials. Requests for comments from various officials, including police and magistrates, went largely unanswered.
Numerous families continue to express both grief and frustration over the delay in compensatory acknowledgment. Families reported spending hours with deceased relatives at the crush sites, often without assistance. One family recounted that they had to carry the body home after authorities failed to provide any help.
This investigation sheds light on the aftermath of a tragedy marked by both loss of life and potential governmental oversight, raising concerns about the transparency of compensation processes for affected families.
Read more on The Global Herald
