Tallahassee isn’t only the state capital of Florida, it’s also a college town that’s home to tens of thousands of students. It also has no shortage of roofers. We reviewed more than twenty roofers in the Tallahassee area, ranking each based on online reviews, proper licensing and Better Business Bureau (BBB) accreditation. Then, we contacted the top-ranking roofers for more information. Here’s what you need to know to find the best roofer in Tallahassee for your home.
There’s a lot to consider when picking a roofer: do they install the type of roofing system you want? What are their warranties like? Will they install protections to keep your dog safe from nails in the grass?
We recommend that you always have a loose idea of the type of roof you want before you call. For example, if you aim to sell your home within a few years, it’s likely a good idea to ensure that when you get your roof replaced, it comes with a transferable warranty. It’s also important to get an idea of the payment policies and cost of a given roofer before you book them. If a job seems prohibitively expensive, don’t hesitate to request an estimate from another roofer.
Total Quality Roofing is our pick for the best overall roofer in Tallahassee. A family business, it has served the area since 1996, installing shingle roofs, metal roofs and more. Its shingles are 50-year Architectural Shingles that come with a transferable warranty. As a GAF Master Elite installer, the company’s GAF shingles also come with a 25-year Golden Pledge workmanship warranty.
Hartsfield Roofing is our top alternative pick in the area. The company is also a family-owned business that installs Owens Corning shingles, along with other types of roofing systems, such as metal. It has very strong reviews across multiple websites.
A family-owned business, Total Quality Roofing opened in 1996. When we called, we were able to speak with the owner, who shared his appreciation for being part of a family business and how his son works alongside the team, with the intention of one day taking over the business himself. The company provides frank customer service you can rely on, with a record proven on multiple review sites.
Total Quality Roofing provides 50-year Architectural Shingles with a transferable warranty. Since the company is a GAF Master Elite installer, these come with up to a 25-year Golden Pledge workmanship warranty. Beyond shingles, the company also works on metal and flat roofs.
Total Quality Roofing does not require a down payment; instead, all payments are due upon completion of the job. When we inquired about financing and credit card payment fees, the owner declined to answer, stating that these financial details would be provided when we “do business,” although he specified that customers are largely very satisfied with his policies.
Services offered
Once the contract is signed, the company will obtain permits and begin work, with most shingle jobs typically completed within two days. That said, if the forecast has a 50% chance of rain or above, they won’t tear the roof off. Instead, they’ll push back to the next dry day.
The company takes protection very seriously. They tarp off the roof and use a magnet to sweep the ground for nails and other fallen hardware. When we asked if the team had undergone background checks, the owner said that, no, they aren’t in the traditional sense, but they are a tight-knit team of 18 that includes the owner’s son. Consequently, he trusts them completely.
Total Quality Roofing is not accredited by the BBB. However, it holds an A+ rating with the bureau, with no registered complaints. It has a 4.9-star rating on Google (134 reviews), a 4.7-star rating on Yelp (11 reviews) and a 4.8-star rating on Angi (161 reviews).
The company is located at 6994 Duck Cove Rd., Tallahassee, Fla., 32312. It is open from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, and is closed on weekends. For an estimate, call 850-222-7663 or visit the website.
Customer testimonial
* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews
Hartsfield Roofing has been operating in Tallahassee since 2008. A family-owned business with roots in Tallahassee, it’s committed to the local community and works on residential and commercial projects.
The company offers Owens Corning Architectural Shingles, which come with a 30-year manufacturer’s warranty and a five-year workmanship warranty that can be extended to up to 25 years. In addition, it installs metal roofs, flat roofs and handles roofing repairs, including emergency storm repairs.
The company doesn’t require down payments to begin; instead, the balance is due upon completion of the job. Credit cards are processed with a 3.5% fee, though other payment options are also available, including financing through the local Commerce Credit Union.
Services offered
Most of the time, Hartsfield Roofing completes shingle roofing jobs in up to two days. However, large storms are a no-go and will cause the company to push back the entire schedule.
When we asked if the team is fully background checked, the representative we spoke to didn’t answer directly. Instead, they said that the team consists entirely of trusted full-time employees. The team takes protection very seriously, sweeping for nails consistently. Regardless, she recommended that homeowners park their cars well away from the building during tear-off and construction to protect their tires and finish from falling hardware.
Hartsfield Roofing is not accredited by the BBB and holds an A- rating with the bureau; however, it has no complaints filed against it. The company has a 4.9-star rating on Google (103 reviews), a five-star rating on Yelp (four reviews) and a 4.9-star rating on Angi (10 reviews).
Hartsfield Roofing is located at 656 Capital Circle Northeast, Tallahassee, Fla., 32301. Its standard hours are 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., Monday through Friday. It is also open 24 hours over the weekend for emergencies. To book an estimate, call Hartsfield Roofing at 850-445-4321 or visit the website.
Customer testimonial
* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews
At Yahoo Local, our mission is to help readers make confident choices when selecting home maintenance providers. While our coverage typically centers on local businesses, there are times when a national roofing company may be the better fit. If you’re deciding between the two, take a look at our guide comparing local and national movers. For those leaning toward a larger provider in Tallahassee, our top recommendation is Erie Home.
Founded in 1976, Erie Home is a major residential roofing contractor serving the Central U.S. and beyond. The company provides standard roofing solutions such as asphalt shingle installation, replacement, and repair, as well as specialized services like metal roofing and waterproofing. Erie operates more than 100 offices across 38 states. While its strongest presence is in the Central and Eastern U.S., it’s also a top national roofing provider for the Southeast and Pacific Northwest, with locations stretching from Washington down to Florida.
Headquartered in Toledo, Ohio, Erie holds an average Google rating of 4.4 stars from over 1,400 reviews, ranking among the highest-rated large roofing providers in its service regions. On Yelp, the company averages two stars from around 40 reviews, a figure that’s typical for national contractors. Based on its overall ratings, service offerings, and proven reliability, Erie Home is our top national roofing company for the Central U.S. and an excellent option for homeowners in both the Southeast and Northwest.
As with most large-scale roofing contractors, Erie Home does not provide pricing over the phone. A company representative explained that costs depend heavily on the details of each project, and an on-site consultation is required for both precise quotes and general estimates.
Customers who choose Erie Home can take advantage of its zero-down financing program, which allows payment deferral for 90 days on roof repairs or replacements. Erie reports that financing is the most common payment method among its clients, and details can be found on the company’s website. Those preferring to pay by credit card, debit card, or check should consult their local Erie office about available options and processing fees.
Services offered
Erie Home is committed to delivering high-quality roofing craftsmanship to its customers. The company specializes in durable metal roofing systems and offers a range of affordable asphalt shingles in multiple color options, including granite black and Monaco red. All installations are backed by a limited lifetime labor warranty, as well as manufacturer warranties that vary by roofing material. Erie also maintains dedicated repair teams capable of responding quickly to service needs. Most roof installations are completed in under a day.
Because Erie operates numerous branches and roofing crews, cleanup procedures can differ between locations. Homeowners should confirm cleanup details with their estimator during the consultation to understand how the crew will handle debris and site cleanup before, during, and after the project.
Erie Home is accredited by the BBB with an A+ rating and has received about 375 customer complaints in the past three years, a number that is considerably lower than the industry average for national roofing firms. According to a company representative, Erie employs only in-house crews and does not use subcontractors. However, we were unable to verify whether formal background checks are conducted on employees.
To learn more about Erie Home, call 800-998-8301 or request a free estimate through the company’s website. Erie’s Tallahassee headquarters is located at 4770 Woodlane Circle, Suite A & C, Tallahassee, Fla., 32303. The company operates offices in 38 states. A full directory and map of Erie Home locations can be found online. Customer service is available 24/7, though hours may vary by office.
Customer testimonial
* See Google reviews * See Yelp reviews
At Yahoo, we’ve spent decades building a reputation for providing reliable information about local businesses. We believe in earning your trust through transparency and effort, not just claiming it. Our proprietary ranking system, for instance, combines user reviews from multiple reputable sources and applies weighted factors to create what we consider the most reliable local business rankings available.
We’re also upfront about how our rankings are determined, so you can evaluate their credibility for yourself. Those details are outlined below. Unlike some competitors, Yahoo Local never accepts payment for inclusion or placement, and our independent recommendations are not “sponsored” or influenced by outside entities. Want to learn more? Visit our full methodology page.
Below is everything that went into the rankings for our list of the best roofing companies in Tallahassee:
A roof replacement will vary substantially in price based on several factors. The roofing type, pitch, square footage and height will all contribute, along with other factors. According to Kelly Roofing, a Florida-based roofer with multiple locations across the state, the cost of most shingle roofs in Florida ranges from $5,000 to $19,000.
This is less than the national average, which we typically estimate to be between $12,000 and $20,000 for a shingle roof. Prices can rise significantly higher than this, though, as roofing materials like slate, tile, and shakes can all cost substantially more.
Unless you have professional roofing experience, hiring a qualified roofer is the best way to determine if your home requires a complete roof replacement. That said, staying proactive helps — homeowners can often identify early signs of roof trouble on their own. Leaks, water spots or missing shingles are clear red flags that should prompt a quick inspection.
It’s also a good idea to schedule inspections before and after major weather events hit. Preparing ahead of hurricane season can help protect your roof. Afterward, it’s important to look for damage immediately. In some situations, your homeowner’s insurance may be more likely to cover inspection or replacement costs if the damage can be linked to a storm.
Florida has two classes of roofing licenses. The first, a Certified Roofing Contractor (CC) license, allows contractors to work on roofs statewide. A Registered Roofing Contractor (RC) license certifies a roofing company for just one region.
For more about these licenses, read our full article on roofer certification in Florida.
Different types of roofing have significantly different lifespans. For example, shingles, metal, and tile all have different lifespans, requiring varying levels of investment.
Kelly Roofing states that most asphalt shingle roofs in Florida typically last between 18 and 25 years. This is just shy of the standard of 20 to 30 years we see across the country. Upkeep and severe storms make a big difference, and Florida’s hurricanes are a true confounding factor.
With Florida’s warm, balmy climate, roofing is viable all year long, with the exception of one factor: hurricane season. While you can technically get your roof done between storms during hurricane season, most residents should wait to see what the season brings. That said, any storm damage should be fixed immediately.
The cooler months after the season finishes are usually a better time to replace a roof. The spring and summer are both good times of year for roofing, as well.
